Democrats voting on 1996-46 | ||
| Daniel Akaka | NO | HI Democrat Jr Senator |
| Jeff Bingaman | NO | NM Democrat Jr Senator |
| Barbara Boxer | NO | CA Democratic incumbent |
| Bill Bradley | NO | NJ Democrat Senator (Former) |
| John Breaux | NO | LA Former Democratic incumbent; retired 2004 |
| Richard Bryan | NO | NV Democrat Jr Senator (Former) |
| Dale Bumpers | NO | AR Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Robert Byrd | NO | WV Democrat Sr Senator |
| Kent Conrad | NO | ND Democrat Sr Senator |
| Tom Daschle | NO | SD Former Democratic Senator (defeated 2004) |
| Chris Dodd | YES | CT Democratic incumbent |
| Byron Dorgan | YES | ND Democratic incumbent |
| Jim Exon | YES | NE Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Russell Feingold | NO | WI Democratic incumbent |
| Dianne Feinstein | NO | CA Democrat Sr Senator |
| Wendell Ford | NO | KY Democrat Senator (Former) |
| John Glenn | YES | OH Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Bob Graham | NO | FL Former Democratic Senator; retired 2004 |
| Fritz Hollings | NO | SC Former Democratic Sr Senator; retired 2004 |
| Daniel Inouye | NO | HI Democratic incumbent |
| Bennett Johnston | YES | LA Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Ted Kennedy | NO | MA Democrat Sr Senator |
| Herbert Kohl | YES | WI Democrat Sr Senator |
| Patrick Leahy | NO | VT Democratic incumbent |
| Joseph Lieberman | YES | CT Democratic Jr Senator; Gore's VP nominee; ran for Pres. 2004 |
| Barbara Mikulski | NO | MD Democratic incumbent |
| Carol Moseley-Braun | YES | IL Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Pat Moynihan | NO | NY Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Patty Murray | NO | WA Democratic incumbent |
| Sam Nunn | YES | GA Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Claiborne Pell | YES | RI Democrat Senator (Former) |
| David Pryor | YES | AR Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Harry Reid | NO | NV Democratic incumbent |
| Charles Robb | NO | VA Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Paul Sarbanes | NO | MD Democrat Sr Senator |
| Paul Simon | NO | IL Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Paul Wellstone | NO | MN Democrat Senator (Former) |
| Ron Wyden | NO | OR Democratic incumbent |
Republicans voting on 1996-46 | ||
| Spencer Abraham | YES | MI Republican Senator (Former) |
| John Ashcroft | YES | MO Republican Senator (Former) |
| Robert Bennett | YES | UT Republican incumbent |
| Kit Bond | YES | MO Republican incumbent |
| Hank Brown | YES | CO Republican Senator (Former) |
| Conrad Burns | YES | MT Former Republican Senator (MT, 1989-2007) |
| Ben Nighthorse Campbell | YES | CO Former Republican incumbent; retired 2004 |
| John Chafee | YES | RI Republican Senator (Former) |
| Daniel Coats | YES | IN Republican Senator (Former) |
| William Cohen | NO | ME Republican Senator (Former) |
| Paul Coverdell | YES | GA Republican Senator (Former) |
| Al D'Amato | NO | NY Former Republican Jr Senator |
| Mike DeWine | YES | OH Republican Sr Senator |
| Bob Dole | YES | KS Republican Senator (Former) |
| Lauch Faircloth | YES | NC Republican Senator (Former) |
| Bill Frist | YES | TN Republican Jr Senator |
| Slade Gorton | YES | WA Republican Senator (Former) |
| Phil Gramm | YES | TX Former Republican Senator |
| Rod Grams | YES | MN Republican Senator (Former) |
| Chuck Grassley | YES | IA Republican incumbent |
| Judd Gregg | YES | NH Republican incumbent |
| Orrin Hatch | YES | UT Republican Sr Senator |
| Mark Hatfield | YES | OR Republican Senator (Former) |
| Jesse Helms | YES | NC Former Republican Sr Senator |
| Kay Bailey Hutchison | YES | TX Republican Jr Senator |
| James Inhofe | YES | OK Republican Sr Senator |
| Nancy Kassebaum | YES | KS Republican Senator (Former) |
| Dirk Kempthorne | YES | ID Republican Governor |
| Jon Kyl | YES | AZ Republican Jr Senator |
| Trent Lott | YES | MS Former Republican Senator (MS, 1989-2007) |
| Richard Lugar | YES | IN Republican Sr Senator |
| Connie Mack | YES | FL Former Republican Senator |
| John McCain | YES | AZ Republican incumbent |
| Frank Murkowski | YES | AK Republican Senator (Former; now Governor) |
| Don Nickles | YES | OK Former Republican incumbent; retired 2004 |
| Larry Pressler | YES | SD Republican Senator (Former) |
| William Roth | NO | DE Former Republican Senator |
| Rick Santorum | YES | PA Republican Jr Senator |
| Richard Shelby | NO | AL Republican incumbent |
| Alan Simpson | NO | WY Republican Senator (Former) |
| Bob Smith | YES | FL Republican challenger; former NH Senator; Constitution Party |
| Olympia Snowe | YES | ME Republican Sr Senator |
| Arlen Specter | NO | PA Republican incumbent |
| Craig Thomas | YES | WY Republican Sr Senator |
| Fred Thompson | YES | TN Republican Sr Senator |
| Strom Thurmond | YES | SC Former Republican Senator |
Independents voting on 1996-46 | ||
| Howell Heflin | NO | AL Former Senator |
| Jim Jeffords | YES | VT Independent Jr Senator |
| Democrats:
YES 11; NO 27
Republicans: YES 40; NO 6 Independents: YES 1; NO 1 |