Why Government Doesn't Work: on Education
Teaching non-academic topics is cause of declining SATs
Learning, as measured by Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) scores, steadily declined throughout the 1960s and 1970s. [I attribute this to] the federal government’s heavy hand transforming the public schools and the private schools as they became
dependent on it. Yesterday’s schools focused on reading, writing, arithmetic, history, and geography. Today’s schools spend much more time teaching children:- To be citizens of the world
- To be sensitive to people who are different than
themselves
- To pester their parents to recycle cans and bottles
- To understand how western civilization destroyed a peaceful North American continent
- To report their parents if they catch them using drugs
- To practice safe sex.
Since none of
those subjects shows up on the SAT tests, it’s not surprising that SAT scores declined so much.
Source: Why Government Doesn’t Work, by H. Browne, p.112-3
Jul 2, 1995
Importance of education no reason for govt control
If important things [like education] must be handled by government, why doesn’t government provide free food-as it provides free schooling? One could live without knowing how to read, but no one can live without food. So why doesn’t government operate
the supermarkets?Imagine what it would be like. The food stores would become what the schools have become. Political battles would decide which foods are available. If you don’t like the choices, you’d have to attend “food board” meetings. Food would
become more and more expensive, even as the quality deteriorated. And don’t get caught praying in a supermarket.
Now let’s reverse the picture. Imagine instead that schools were operated like today’s supermarkets. Most school systems would offer a
variety of approaches to any one subject-just as a supermarket offers a variety of brands for any one food item. And if you didn’t like what one school offered, or if you didn’t like the way your child was treated, you could patronize another school.
Source: Why Government Doesn’t Work, by Harry Browne, p.115
Jul 2, 1995
Vouchers better than public schools; no govt is best
The success of private schools-even private schools on skimpy budgets-has inspired the idea of “school choice” or “vouchers.” I understand well the attraction of this approach. And it might be an improvement over today’s poor schooling.
But government
doesn’t work. And giving government control over education-in any form-is dangerous. A voucher program means requires a government bureaucracy to administer it and government “experts” to decide which schools are “qualified” to accept the vouchers.
It
is especially dangerous to have the federal government administer such a program or set the rules for it. The Feds are too far removed from local school issues to have any competence in education.
It is far better to lower the tax burden so that
parents are financially able to buy the education they want-with no rules imposed by government. Then each family could send its children to any school they want-or teach them at home.
Source: Why Government Doesn’t Work, by Harry Browne, p.116
Jul 2, 1995
Feds out of education and states out of education
There are two important changes that must be made to improve education:- The federal government must get completely out of education. It has made a bad situation much worse. And it has no Constitutional authority to meddle in education in any way-
even if it were capable of helping.
- Federal taxes must be lowered dramatically so that parents have the ability to finance their children’s education directly.
Once we make these reforms, it will be up to the people in each state to
decide what educational system is best.- Some states will revert to the kind of education provided before the federal government took over-with public schools that reflect local values and circumstances.
- Some states will adopt a voucher system, in
order to enhance freedom of choice and lessen dependence on government.
- And some states will withdraw from education altogether-reducing taxes so parents can buy whatever education they want for their children.
Source: Why Government Doesn’t Work, by Harry Browne, p.117
Jul 2, 1995
Page last updated: Feb 26, 2019