OnTheIssues.org


Home Issues Leaders Recent Grid Archive Senate House VoteMatch_Quiz FAQs
 2012 Election:  Obama's book Biden's book Romney's book Ryan's book  |  Jill Stein's interview Gary Johnson's interview  |   2012   Debates 

Books by and about 2012 presidential nominees
Do Not Ask What Good We Do
about Rep. Paul Ryan (2012)
The Path to Prosperity
by Rep. Paul Ryan (2012)
Ten Letters
about Pres. Barack Obama (2011)
A Life of Trial and Redemption
about V.P. Joe Biden (2010)
No Apology
by Gov. Mitt Romney (2010)
Young Guns
by Rep. Paul Ryan et al (2010)
The Path to Prosperity
by Rep. Paul Ryan (2012)
Promises to Keep
by Vice Pres. Joe Biden (2007)
The Audacity of Hope
by Pres. Barack Obama (2006)
Turnaround
by Gov. Mitt Romney (2004)
Dreams from My Father
by Pres. Barack Obama (1996)

Book Reviews

(from Amazon.com)

(click a book cover for a review or other books by or about the presidency from Amazon.com)

John McCain: An American Odyssey,
by Robert Timberg



(Click for Amazon book review)

Click here for 4 full quotes from John McCain in the book An American Odyssey, by Robert Timberg.
OR click on an issue category below for a subset.

OnTheIssues.org BOOK REVIEW:

This book was written in 1999 (when McCain first ran for president and lost the GOP primary to Bush) and then "re-issued" in 2007 (when McCain ran for president and got the GOP nomination). In other words, its purpose is a biography for a presidential candidate. And it's a favorable biography (not authorized, but definitely favorable), which means it's McCain's story framed the way McCain would like his story framed. If every reporter -- and the voting public -- had framed McCain's story this way in 2000 -- or in 2008 -- McCain likely would have won the presidency.

A bit about the history of this book. Robert Timberg first wrote it in 1995 as A Nightingale's Song, a description of five graduates of Annapolis, including McCain, who was then a Senator. In 1999, when McCain ran for President, Timberg excerpted out the McCain parts, added some new material, and created this semi-new book. In 2007, the re-issued version didn't add any new material except a new 11-page foreword. That new foreword is not nearly as favorable to McCain as the rest of the book. Timberg, evidently, deeply admired McCain in 1999, but not so much in 2007 (but enough to re-issue a positive book). Timberg was an Annapolis graduate himself -- hence the first book -- and then a reporter for the Baltimore Sun -- hence the admiration for McCain in 2000, as all reporters admired McCain then (even OnTheIssues' reporters!).

So, let's outline the pro-McCain framework that Timberg wrote when he admired McCain:

  • McCain's war stance is framed as an outcome of lessons from Vietnam: Stay out of most wars (he opposed Lebanon in 1983, p. 151, and opposed Haiti in 1994, p. 191); but if we get in, see it through (as in Kosovo in 1999, p. 205). This actually explains McCain's support for "the surge" in 2007 in Iraq without painting his as a warmonger; but doesn't explain his support for invading Iraq in 2002 in the first place.

  • The Keating Five incident -- in which five Senators were accused of impropriety in a banking scandal -- is framed with McCain as exhibiting bad judgment (p. 184) while three others involved were reprimanded and didn't run for re-election. This issue didn't resonate as an issue in the 2000 campaign, in any case, which is why most voters barely recognize the term "Keating Five" anymore.

  • While McCain was a POW in Vietnam, his wife Carol was crippled in a car accident, and she didn't tell McCain (p. 104); McCain left her shortly after his return (p. 128). This issue is framed as favorably as possible, that the couple had drifted apart after 6 years of separation. But then McCain married a young heiress (p. 135) and ran for office, which could have been framed as opportunistic, but is framed instead as McCain "starting over" after his long imprisonment (p. 136).

OnTheIssues expanded our excerpts of this book (and several other McCain books and others) in preparation for the 2016 presidential election. What role McCain plays in 2016 is an open question: perhaps elder statesman; perhaps behind-the-scene adviser; perhaps Sarah Palin's supporter. So we'll see.

-- Jesse Gordon, editor-in-chief, OnTheIssues.org, August 2014

 OnTheIssues.org excerpts:  (click on issues for details)
Principles & Values
    As teenager, inherited obligation to attend Annapolis.
    Admiral Slew McCain set Johnís standard for grit & courage.
    Born at a Naval Air Station in the Panama Canal Zone.
    Relationship with father was one of respect, more than love.


    Click for quotations from other sources by:
  • John McCain

The above quotations are from John McCain: An American Odyssey,
by Robert Timberg.

Logo
All material copyright 1999-2013
by OnTheIssues.org
Reprinting by permission only.

E-mail: submit@OnTheIssues.org
Mail
Send donations or submit quotations to:
OnTheIssues.org
1770 Massachusetts Ave. #630
Cambridge, MA 02140



OnTheIssues.org
Home Page
Most recent quotations Archive of books & debates Candidate Matching Quiz

Page last edited: Jan 31, 2013