issues2000.org


Home Issues Leaders Recent Grid Archive Senate House VoteMatch_Quiz FAQs
 2008 Election:  McCain's book Obama's book Biden's book Palin's booklet Keyes' book Nader's book Barr's book      2008   Debates 

2008 presidential race

2009 State of the Union speech
Presidential Debates: Third Obama-McCain Debate - Second Obama-McCain Debate - V.P. debate, Biden vs. Palin - First Obama-McCain Debate
Vice Presidential background materials:

Gov. Sarah Palin: Booklet - Debate - Profile - Wasilla - Governor
Sen. Joe Biden: Bio - Profile - Debates
Convention coverage:
Dems - GOP - McCain - Palin - Obama - Biden - Nader - Barr
McCain-Obama joint appearances:
Aug.16 -Jul.12 -Jun.28 -
Fox -CNN -
MtP -Ads
2008 Democratic primary debates
Apr.16 -Apr.13 -Feb.26 -Feb.21 -Feb.11 -Jan.31 -Jan.28 -Jan.21 -Jan.15 -Jan.5
2008 Republican primary debates
Feb.7 -Jan.30 -Jan.28 -Jan.24 -Jan.10 -Jan.6 -Jan.5
2008 Green primary debates
Feb.3 -Jan.13
2007 Republican primary debates
Dec.22 -Dec.12 -Dec.9 -Nov.28 -Oct.21 -Oct.9 -Sep.27 -Sep.17 -Sep.5 -Aug.5 -Jun.5 -May 15 -May 3
2007 Democratic primary debates
Dec.22 -Dec.13 -Dec.4 -Dec.1 -Nov.15 -Oct.30 -Sep.26 -Sep.20 -Sep.13 -Sep.9 -Aug.19 -Aug.9 -Aug.7 -Jul.23 -Jun.28 -Jun.3 -Apr.26 -Apr.10


Excerpts from Books by and about 2008 candidates
Sen. John McCain (R, AZ)
Why Courage Matters
Sen. Barack Obama(D, IL)
Dreams From My Father
Sen. Joe Biden (D, DE)
Promises to Keep
Gov. Sarah Palin (R, AK)
New Energy for Alaska
Rep. Bob Barr (L)
The Meaning of IS
Rep. Cynthia McKinney (G)
Green Party Debate
Ralph Nader (I)
The Good Fight
Alan Keyes (NAIP)
Our Character, Our Future

Sen. Hillary Clinton
It Takes A Village
Mayor Rudy Giuliani
Leadership
Gov. Mike Huckabee
Character Makes A Difference
Amb. Alan Keyes
Our Character, Our Future
Rep. Ron Paul
Freedom Under Siege
Gov. Mitt Romney
Turnaround

(click a book cover for excerpts and a review or other books by or about the presidency from Amazon.com)

Obamanomics
How Bottom-Up Economic Prosperity Will Replace Trickle-Down Economics
, by John R. Talbott



(Click for Amazon book review)

BOOK REVIEW by OnTheIssues.org:

This book leaves a bad taste in my mouth. The reader must be careful when reading, because the author's views are mixed in with Obama's views, with too little distinction between the two. This book is supposedly a pro-Obama economist's analysis of Obama's policy stances -- that's a fine goal. But it turns out to be more like the author's manifesto of his own policy stances, framed around Obama's campaign.

For example, the author writes that Obama "has suggested holding frequent town hall meetings with government representatives on the Internet, and he would be well advised to encourage much of his administration's business, as well as congressional deliberations, to be televised on C-SPAN to prevent secret dealings that harm the people." (p. 48) The FIRST part of that sentence is Obama's policy; the SECOND half of that sentence is not!

If the author, John Talbott, were a leading economic advisor to Obama, it would make sense to merge his own views with Obama's as an explanation of their sources. But he's not on Obama's team -- so one wonders why Talbott chose to write this book. It seems that he's an economic-advisor-wannabe -- that he's using this book to infiltrate his views into the Obama campaign because he could not figure out how to get onto the campaign staff.

For example, Talbott writes about predatory lending, "What else can Obama do to prevent crises like these from occurring again? I have some opinions that I would like to share with you, in the hopes that Obama's financial advisors may end up hearing them and then convince Obama to adopt them. To my knowledge, Obama has never mentioned these or similar proposals." (p. 90) Well, ok, why doesn't Talbott go tell OBAMA rather than telling US so that Obama might hear it? Do we really need to care about Talbott's opinions that he cannot get Obama's own economists to get Obama to mention?

Worse, Talbott proposes policy stances that are not economic. Talbott DOES have economic expertise -- but when he "advises" Obama on non-economic issues, he's just another citizen, and we wonder why we should care about his opinion.

For example, Talbott writes in his corporate lobbying chapter, "What better way to involve all our citizens than to ask them to vote once a month using their cell phones or the Internet on important issues? While Obama has not suggested such a nationwide poll, he would be well advised to consider it." (p. 109-110) He should? Such a poll would provide a cross-section of opinion that is skewed towards the upper-class who have cell phones and Internet access -- and would play into criticisms of Obama as an elitist. That's just MY opinion, as a political analyst -- but my opinion is just as valid as Talbott's on non-economic issues. Why should Obama listen to Talbott on political issues, and why should the reader?

If we had not gotten so caught up in the problem of merged opinion, we would have commented effusively on the economic analysis in this book, and on the clever title. "Obamanomics" is a catchy phrase that is not much used -- others HAVE used it, but Talbott will get credit for it, because of this book title, if it gets adopted into general usage. What Talbott means by "Obamanomics" is a focus on bottom-up economics (focusing on people's interest over corporate interests, in philosophical conjunction with Obama's more well-known internet-based bottom-up politics). "Reaganomics" came to mean the opposite "trickle-down economics", and "Clintonomics" came to mean triangulation between GOP and Democratic views to determine what could pass Congress. No one has defined "Bushonomics" or "McCainonomics" but we look forward to those terms too.

Our excerpts attempt to correct the major shortcoming of this book, by carefully reading and separating out Talbott's opinions from Obama's opinions. We cite "Op-Ed" where we consider Talbott's opinions to be relevant enough to excerpt (like on page 39). This book WOULD be a fine economic analysis -- if Talbott could more clearly separate opinion from analysis. But because he does not, it's a tricky book to read, and not recommended beyond our excerpts.

-- Jesse Gordon, jesse@OnTheIssues.org, July 2008

NOTE: We review ANOTHER book with this same title here: Obamanomics, by Timothy P. Carney

Click here for 32 full quotes from Barack Obama in the book Obamanomics, by John R. Talbott.
OR click on an issue category below for a subset.
Budget & Economy
   Bottom-up economics instead of trickle-down economics.
   Focus on economic justice instead of macroeconomic policy.
   We need both bottom-up politics and bottom-up economics.
   OpEd: "Hope" translates into economic opportunity.
   Free market needs proper government oversight.
   Prosecute mortgager fraud; require full mortgage disclosure.
Civil Rights
   Past discrimination affects future generations.
Corporations
   Enforce against insider trading & market manipulation.
   Regulate institutions for what they do, not what they are.
Education
   Make math & science policy a national priority.
Energy & Oil
   Political climate at fault for failing energy independence.
   Include clean coal in clean energy future.
Environment
   Support reforestation as carbon sequestration issue.
Families & Children
   Zero-to-Five plan: childcare for working parents.
Foreign Policy
   OpEd: Policy views based on experience in Kenya & Indonesia.
Free Trade
   NAFTA protects corporate profits; should protect labor.
   Supports trade & globalization but opposes CAFTA job loss.
   Assist workers who lose globalization's race to the bottom.
   Peru trade OK because it includes labor & enviro protections.
Government Reform
   Google for Government: let public track federal grants.
   Cabinet members should hold national town hall meetings.
Health Care
   When your child gets sick, you don't shop for best bargain.
   If we started from scratch, one-payer system would be best.
Immigration
   Crack down on employers who hire illegal immigrants.
Jobs
   Expand paid sick days to seven per year.
   Supports Fair Pay Act: equal pay for equal work.
   Employee Free Choice Act: right to organize harassment-free.
Principles & Values
   Emphasis on cooperation and listening to both sides.
   Michelle: My husband demands you move out of comfort zone.
Social Security
   What do we do with the losers of privatizing?.
Tax Reform
   Maintain the inheritance tax on wealthy.
Technology
   Invest in a digital smart grid for electricity utilities.


The above quotations are from Obamanomics
How Bottom-Up Economic Prosperity Will Replace Trickle-Down Economics
, by John R. Talbott.

Logo
All material copyright 1999-2013
by OnTheIssues.org
Reprinting by permission only.

E-mail: submit@OnTheIssues.org
Mail
Send donations or submit quotations to:
OnTheIssues.org
1770 Massachusetts Ave. #630
Cambridge, MA 02140



OnTheIssues.org
Home Page
Most recent quotations Archive of books & debates Candidate Matching Quiz