Welfare & Labor: Presidential Candidates' views

Welfare & Labor pop-up Grid
(best for slow modems)

Candidate Quiz
(match your preferences)
Click on a candidate below to see their Welfare & Labor headlines.
Click on the headline's date to see full quotations.
Go back
to the main page.
Support Issues2000!
(We need your donations!)
Most recent quote
on Welfare & Labor

Archive
(books and debates)

Headlines on Welfare & Labor

Background on Welfare & Labor

Quotations on Welfare & Labor
Al Gore
Alan Keyes
Bill Bradley
Donald Trump
Gary Bauer
George W. Bush
Harry Browne
Hillary Clinton
Howard Phillips
John McCain
Orrin Hatch
Pat Buchanan
Rudy Giuliani
Steve Forbes

Also see:

Candidates on...
Foreign Trade
Corporate welfare
Earned-income Tax Credits

Related sites:
Welfare-to-Work
Welfare Reform Bill
Devolution
AFL-CIO site
Labor policy.com
Welfare policy.com

    Welfare-to-Work

  • The welfare reform bill, signed by President Clinton in 1996, ended the federal entitlement to welfare, imposed strict work requirements on recipients, and set a five-year lifetime limit for aid.
  • In 1995, 88% of poor children received food stamps. By 1998 the figure had dropped to 70%.
  • The welfare load currently stands at about 2 million recipients, which has dropped by about 1/3 since the welfare reform bill was enacted.

    Faith-Based Organizations

  • As welfare decreases, churches and other faith-based organizations (FBOs) pick up the slack.
  • Churches are tax-exempt, and donations to churches and other charities are tax-deductible, so federal activity focuses on tax reform to encourage donations, by increasing deductibility on federal and state income taxes.
  • Other recent Congressional bills focus on removing restrictions on religious organizations' activities, so that churches can bid on government block grants for performing welfare services.
  • The lessening of restrictions on separation of church and state for this purpose is known as Charitable Choice.

    Labor Issues

  • Total union membership stands at about 16 million workers, or 14% of the workforce.
  • Union membership has been falling steadily since 1958, when it stood at 35% of the workforce.
  • The minimum wage is currently $5.15. Increasing it requires an act of Congress. Some candidates want to increase it now, and automatically increase it to keep up with inflation (known as "indexing").

Foreign trade and import regulations are covered on the Free Trade page.
Corporate welfare issues are covered on the Government Reform page.
Earned-income Tax Credits are covered on the Tax Reform page.


(click a book cover for a review or click for other books on Welfare or Labor from Amazon.com.)

Most recent quote on Welfare & Labor

Background on Welfare & Labor
Home

Headlines on Welfare & Labor

Welfare & Labor Pop-up grid

Quotations on Welfare & Labor


Al Gore on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 11 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Al Gore, in context.
Oct 28, 1999    Expand Family and Medical Leave to balance work & family.
      Task force to study industrial needs.
      Proposes sweeping Federal programs, $Billions, for needy.
      Add $1 to minimum wage; add earned-income credits.
      Supports volunteerism thru faith-based organizations.
      Corporations should match donations to faith-based orgs.
      “Charitable Choice:” Fed funds for church-based welfare.
      Faith-based organizations replace govt programs.
      Invest in urban redevelopment and “Empowerment Zones”.
      Injuries can be reduced by workers self-identifying hazards.
      Set goals & provide tools to reach goals locally.

Alan Keyes on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 3 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Alan Keyes, in context.
Oct 29, 1999    Volunteer for community service; not via government funding.
      Shift welfare from government to the faith sector.
      Disintegration of the family causes social ills.

Bill Bradley on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 8 full quotes
OR
Click here for 2 older headlines
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Bill Bradley, in context.
Dec 31, 1999    Strengthen unionization laws & defend right-to-organize.
      Economy, not laws, changed welfare stats.
      Raise minimum wage; more unions; low-income tax cuts.
      Supports unions for home-health & day-care workers.
      Fundamental changes in welfare law needed.
      Bad ideas: block grants; 5-year cutoff.
      Good ideas: federal commitment, address single-parenting.
      Welfare should not require mothers to work.

Donald Trump on Welfare & Labor
No stance on record.

Gary Bauer on Welfare & Labor
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Gary Bauer, in context. May 24, 1999    Supports faith-based solutions for social ills.

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 10 full quotes
OR
Click here for 7 older headlines
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by George W. Bush, in context.
Dec 9, 1999    Supports low-income heating oil assistance program.
      Work and responsibility to replace welfare.
      Too much government fosters dependency.
      Religious charities deserve government support.
      Government should not block faith-based programs.
      Churches provide “armies of compassion” to help the poor.
      Look first to faith-based organizations.
      Religious groups compete for state service contracts.
      Invigorate “a Civil Society” to protect vulnerable citizens.
      Help people become independent of welfare.

Harry Browne on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 4 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Harry Browne, in context.
May 1, 1996    End welfare completely; no entitlements to others’ earnings.
      War on Poverty & rent control cause poverty & homelessness.
      Supports enterprise zones; eliminate govt regulations.
      End welfare; return to private compassion & charity.

Hillary Clinton on Welfare & Labor
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Hillary Clinton, in context. Oct 24, 1999    The working poor deserve a living wage.

Howard Phillips on Welfare & Labor
No stance on record.

John McCain on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 4 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by John McCain, in context.
Feb 25, 1999    List unoccupied HUD-owned homes, & give them away.
      Use tax code to address unemployment & working conditions.
      More housing assistance; tax breaks against homelessness.
      Pro-block grants; pro-welfare-to-work.

Orrin Hatch on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 7 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Orrin Hatch, in context.
Sep 22, 1998    Raising the minimum wage causes “disemployment”.
      Minimum wage jobs are first jobs; workers go on to others.
      Replace minimum wage increases with cut taxes & education.
      Supports welfare reform from dependency to self-sufficiency.
      Welfare should be a transitional program, not permanent.
      Replace hand outs with hand up via job training.
      Block grants let local programs work; fed programs do not.

Pat Buchanan on Welfare & Labor
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Pat Buchanan, in context. Sep 20, 1999    Corporations are “amoral behemoths”.

Rudy Giuliani on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 3 full quotes
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Rudy Giuliani, in context.
Dec 9, 1999    Change welfare offices into job centers; employed 45.
      305,000 jobs created during Rudy’s tenure.
      460,000 moved off welfare rolls during Rudy’s tenure.

Steve Forbes on Welfare & Labor
Click here for 6 full quotes
OR
Click here for 1 older headlines
OR
Click on the date to the right for the most recent quote by Steve Forbes, in context.
Dec 13, 1999    Raise wages by allowing growth, not by fiat.
      Raise wages by allowing growth, not by fiat.
      Federal welfare is devolving to state and community.
      ‘Homestead Act’ for tenants to own projects.
      Charitable deduction gone under Flat Tax; but giving is not.
      Supports Enterprise Zones as welfare opporunity.

Most recent quote on Welfare & Labor

Background on Welfare & Labor
Home

Quotations on Welfare & Labor

Welfare & Labor Pop-up grid

Headlines on Welfare & Labor


(click a book cover for a review or click for other books on Welfare or Labor from Amazon.com.)

Al Gore on Welfare & Labor: Oct 28, 1999

Expand Family and Medical Leave to balance work & family

Q: What will you do as president to provide leadership to get our country working better for everybody, working people as well as CEOs? A: I have talked with so many working parents who are really stressed out trying to balance work and family. It’s hard. I want to expand the Family and Medical Leave Act. They ought to - you also ought to - have the right to go to parent-teacher meetings and doctors appointments. It ought to be easier to balance work and family.
Source: Democrat Debate at Dartmouth College
Click here for 11 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Alan Keyes on Welfare & Labor: Oct 29, 1999

Volunteer for community service; not via government funding

Q: Do you support funding for national community service programs such as AmeriCorps? A: I am a great believer in volunteerism in this country, but I think it’s time we understood that it ought to be just that. The business of helping one another is a business that ought to be centered in the private sector, in the faith sector in this country. I think government’s involvement has been detrimental.
Source: Republican Debate at Dartmouth College

Alan Keyes on Welfare & Labor: Oct 29, 1999

Shift welfare from government to the faith sector

Government has botched up the welfare program, because when you enter the business of helping folks and - to put it frankly - you help them without the sermon, I think you do them harm. Efforts in which we are aiming to achieve mutual help for one another should be put back in the hands of the private and faith sector in this country.
Source: Republican Debate at Dartmouth College
Click here for 3 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Bill Bradley on Welfare & Labor: Dec 31, 1999

Strengthen unionization laws & defend right-to-organize

“The union movement is critical to improving the standard of living for working families,” Bradley told 100 picketing Teamsters workers. “You need somebody on your side. I’m on your side.” Bradley favors tougher right-to-organize legislation, an increase in the minimum wage, and broader health-care coverage. Bradley spoke about his proposals to triple penalties for firing union organizers. “I want to put some teeth in the law that says you can’t fire someone who’s organizing,” Bradley said.
Source: Bergen Record, p. A3
Click here for 8 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Donald Trump on Welfare & Labor

No stance on record.

Gary Bauer on Welfare & Labor: May 24, 1999

Supports faith-based solutions for social ills

I strongly support the heroic work being done by churches, non-profits, and people of faith and compassion to reach out to drug addicts, prisoners, and women facing problem pregnancies. For example, the Step Academy [in VA] helps inner city men and women through a two-year job and skills training program. The Jobs Partnership [in NC] similarly provides a dynamic private sector alternative to bureaucratic government management. As President, I will encourage and expand these efforts.
Source: www.bauer2k.com/html/indepthissues.html 5/24/99

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Supports low-income heating oil assistance program

Bush said he strongly backed a federal program to provide heating oil assistance to low-income residents. “I do support LIHEAP,” Bush said, referring to the federal Low Income Heat & Energy Assistance Program, which has provided billions in relief to families during the cold winter months. At last week’s debate, Bush said he would push for more oil exploration but did not mention LIHEAP. However, he said he has always backed the program and would oppose efforts in Congress to impose cuts.
Source: Boston Herald, p. 14

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Work and responsibility to replace welfare

    I proposed two sweeping welfare reform packages, to:
  • place time limits on welfare benefits;
  • require able-bodied welfare recipients to get a job, attend school, or train for work;
  • require participating mothers to identify the fathers of their children so they could contribute to their support;
  • and emphasize personal responsibility by requiring welfare recipients to sign an independence contract pledging to stay drug-free and keep their kids immunized and in school.
Source: “A Charge to Keep”, p. 32

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Too much government fosters dependency

The new culture said if people were poor, the government should feed them. If criminals are not responsible for their acts, then the answers are not in prisons, but in social programs. People became less interested in pulling themselves up by their bootstraps and more interested in pulling down a monthly government check. A culture of dependency was born. Programs that began as a temporary hand-up became a permanent handout, regarded by many as a right.
Source: “A Charge to Keep”, p.229-230

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Religious charities deserve government support

Participation in faith-based programs must be voluntary, and we must make sure secular alternatives are available. But government should welcome the active involvement of people who are following a religious imperative to love their neighbors through after-school programs, child care, drug treatment, maternity group homes, and a range of other services. Supporting these men and women. is the next bold step of welfare reform.
Source: “A Charge to Keep”, p.232

George W. Bush on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Government should not block faith-based programs

It seemed to me that a government that truly wants to help people should welcome the active involvement of people of faith, not throw up roadblocks or stifle their efforts with bureaucratic red tape.. I assembled a task force to recommend ways that churches and synagogues and mosques and other faith-based or private institutions could work with government to help people in need without violating the important principle of separation of church and state, compromising the religious nature of their mission, or being shackled by government intrusion. I believe in the power of faith to change lives.
Source: “A Charge to Keep”, p.213-215
Click here for 10 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Harry Browne on Welfare & Labor: May 1, 1996

End welfare completely; no entitlements to others’ earnings

End welfare completely, so that children no longer believe that they are entitled to the earnings of others.
Source: Project Vote Smart, 1996, www.vote-smart.org

Harry Browne on Welfare & Labor: May 1, 1996

War on Poverty & rent control cause poverty & homelessness

Browne does not support tax incentives for companies to hire and train homeless people; nor increasing spending on low income housing projects; nor expanding the earned-income tax credit for low income families. Browne says, “Federal urban renewal programs, the War on Poverty, welfare, rent control, and housing regulations are the primary causes of enduring poverty and homelessness.”
Source: Project Vote Smart, 1996, www.vote-smart.org

Harry Browne on Welfare & Labor: May 1, 1996

Supports enterprise zones; eliminate govt regulations

Browne would eliminate government regulations to encourage investment and economic expansion of the private sector. Browne says, “Enterprise zones are very valuable; they free companies from oppressive regulations and taxes, so they can hire more people, lower their prices, and improve their communities.”
Source: Project Vote Smart, 1996, www.vote-smart.org

Harry Browne on Welfare & Labor: May 1, 1996

End welfare; return to private compassion & charity

End welfare entirely and return to the traditional American system of relying on churches, charities, and private compassion.
Source: Project Vote Smart, 1996, www.vote-smart.org
Click here for 4 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Hillary Clinton on Welfare & Labor: Oct 24, 1999

The working poor deserve a living wage

We should be working to keep a basic bargain with all Americans: If you work hard and are responsible, you will not live in poverty. If you study this issue, you can clearly see it will not hurt the economy, it will not increase unemployment. There are those who have opposed an increase in the minimum wage, arguing that it will cost jobs, and there are some people who say we need more studies.. They are wrong.
Source: Speech in Queens

Howard Phillips on Welfare & Labor

No stance on record.

John McCain on Welfare & Labor: Feb 25, 1999

List unoccupied HUD-owned homes, & give them away

McCain introduced the “Urban Homestead Act” (S.485), which would publish a list of unoccupied multifamily housing projects, substandard housing projects, and other residential property owned by the federal government (HUD); and would transfer ownership to a requesting community development corporation, after HUD satisfies any related indebtedness.
Source: Senate statements S.485
Click here for 4 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Orrin Hatch on Welfare & Labor: Sep 22, 1998

Raising the minimum wage causes “disemployment”

[Some people] believe that an increase in the minimum wage is a quick, painless way to help the disadvantaged in our society. I can only wonder then why they have not offered raising the minimum wage to $15, $20, or $30 an hour. There is indeed an adverse effect on employment. For every 10% increase in the minimum wage, the disemployment effect was between 100,000 to 300,000 jobs. Disemployment means jobs not only eliminated, but also jobs that are never created in the first place.
Source: senate.gov/~hatch “Statements”

Orrin Hatch on Welfare & Labor: Sep 22, 1998

Minimum wage jobs are first jobs; workers go on to others

It is a great myth that everyone currently earning the minimum wage gets “stuck” in a minimum wage job. The fact is that people cycle through these jobs regularly. They get raises; they get more education; they learn a new skill; they prove themselves reliable; they move on and up. First jobs are for learning as well as earning. If we continue to raise the bar for entry, how many adults will we have who have never worked? How many teenagers and young adults who need a chance are not going to get one?
Source: senate.gov/~hatch “Statements”

Orrin Hatch on Welfare & Labor: Sep 22, 1998

Replace minimum wage increases with cut taxes & education

Hiking the minimum wage is not the only way to assist working Americans and those struggling to make ends meet. I’d like to raise people’s paychecks by cutting their taxes. I think we can work together on education. Education - or the lack of it - is the biggest factor in determining an individual’s earning capacity. Let’s tackle illiteracy and other root causes of low-skills and low-earnings potential. But, for heaven’s sake, let’s recognize the minimum wage as the mirage it really is.
Source: senate.gov/~hatch “Statements”
Click here for 7 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Pat Buchanan on Welfare & Labor: Sep 20, 1999

Corporations are “amoral behemoths”

[Buchanan] denounces America’s leading corporations as “amoral behemoths,” whose “loyalty is only to the bottom line.” He warns: “If they shut down factories here to open overseas, they will pay a price for the readmission of their goods into America’s market.”
Source: Jeff Jacoby editorial, Boston Globe

Rudy Giuliani on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

Change welfare offices into job centers; employed 45

While New York City used to be called the welfare capital of the country, under Rudy Giuliani’s leadership, the City has developed the largest and most successful welfare to work initiative in the nation. When Rudy took office, more than one in seven New Yorkers were receiving public assistance. Welfare dependency had become a problem effecting generations of New Yorkers. New York’s welfare reforms anticipated the changes in the Federal law. By changing welfare offices into job centers, Rudy Giuliani has helped move over 450,000 New Yorkers from a state of dependency to the dignity of work. Those who remain on public assistance participate in the City’s work experience program in exchange for their benefits. By reasserting the value of the social contract, which says that for every right there is a responsibility, Rudy Giuliani has helped restore the work ethic to the heart of life in New York.
Source: RudyYes.com, “Proven Leadership” web site

Rudy Giuliani on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

305,000 jobs created during Rudy’s tenure

Over the past five years, the City has gained over 305,000 broad-based private sector jobs, which is 99% of the private sector jobs lost before the Mayor came into office. This five-year period has yielded the greatest job growth in the City’s history, 1998 being the strongest to date. For the first time in many years, NYC’s economy has grown at a faster rate than the Nation’s economy.
Source: RudyYes.com, “Proven Leadership” web site

Rudy Giuliani on Welfare & Labor: Dec 9, 1999

460,000 moved off welfare rolls during Rudy’s tenure

  • More than 460,000 have moved off the welfare rolls since March 1995.
  • There have been more than 250,000 participants in the City’s Workfare program since it began in March 1995.
  • In November, Mayor Giuliani toured the Hamilton Job Center in Harlem to celebrate the completion of New York City’s eighth Job Center.
  • The Human Resources Administration continues the transformation of Welfare Centers into Job Centers to bring more New Yorkers from welfare to work
Source: RudyYes.com, “Proven Leadership” web site
Click here for 3 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Steve Forbes on Welfare & Labor: Dec 13, 1999

Raise wages by allowing growth, not by fiat

Q: Do you support the elimination of the minimum wage? A: If a state has a minimum wage, and they want to get rid of it, fine. But they are under federal law. We have a [federal] minimum wage and there’s no way they can opt out of that. But the best way to raise wages in this country is not through government decree. The way to do it is remove barriers to people getting ahead, have investment incentives, get more growth than we have today, which we’re capable of doing, and productivity - not by fiat.
Source: Des Moines Iowa GOP Debate

Steve Forbes on Welfare & Labor: Dec 13, 1999

Raise wages by allowing growth, not by fiat

Q: Do you support the elimination of the minimum wage? A: If a state has a minimum wage, and they want to get rid of it, fine. But they are under federal law. We have a [federal] minimum wage and there’s no way they can opt out of that. But the best way to raise wages in this country is not through government decree. The way to do it is remove barriers to people getting ahead, have investment incentives, get more growth than we have today, which we’re capable of doing, and productivity - not by fiat.
Source: Des Moines Iowa GOP Debate
Click here for 6 full quotes on Welfare & Labor

Issues2000.org

Viewers of all Issues pages since August 1999:

(click a book cover for a review or click for other books on Welfare or Labor from Amazon.com.)


Logo
All material copyright 1999
by Issues2000.org
Reprinting by permission only.

E-mail: submit@issues2000.org Mail
Send donations or submit quotations to:
Issues 2000
1770 Massachusetts Ave. #630
Cambridge, MA 02140


DCOrbit

Issues 2000
WM_logo Written by
WebMerchants

IWP_logo Powered by
Instant Web Page

Most Recent on Welfare & Labor Welfare & Labor Pop-up Grid Welfare & Labor Headlines by date Help out

Click Here!